TITLE 9. ENVIRONMENT

STATE WATER CONTROL BOARD

Fast-Track Regulation

Title of Regulation: 9VAC25-210. Virginia Water Protection Permit Program Regulation (amending 9VAC25-210-320, 9VAC25-210-340, 9VAC25-210-360).

Statutory Authority: § 62.1-44.15 of the Code of Virginia; § 401 of the Clean Water Act (33 USC § 1251 et seq.).

Public Hearing Information: No public hearing is currently scheduled.

Public Comment Deadline: October 21, 2026.

Effective Date: November 5, 2026.

Agency Contact: Eric Seavey, Department of Environmental Quality, 1111 East Main Street, Suite 1400, P.O. Box 1105, Richmond, VA 23218, telephone (804) 754-6250, or email eric.seavey@deq.virginia.gov.

Basis: Section 62.1-44.15 of the Code of Virginia authorizes the State Water Control Board to adopt regulations to enforce the general water quality management program of the board in all or part of the Commonwealth. Section 62.1-44.15:22 of the Code of Virginia authorizes the board to include conditions in a Virginia Water Protection (VWP) permit regarding the volume of water that may be withdrawn as part of the permitted activity and conditions necessary to protect beneficial uses.

Purpose: This action is essential to the public health, safety, and welfare because it clarifies the regulation, which protects water quality in the Commonwealth.

Rationale for Using Fast-Track Rulemaking Process: This action is expected to be noncontroversial and therefore appropriate for the fast-track rulemaking process because the amendments improve clarity and certainty for the regulated community and the agency by making requirements in the VWP regulation consistent with the amendments to Local and Regional Water Supply Planning (9VAC25-780) that became effective October 9, 2024. The updates to the affected sections do not change existing requirements for a potential applicant or an applicant for a VWP permit.

Substance: The amendments (i) update references and terminology to clarify pre-application procedures for new or expanded surface water withdrawals under the VWP Permit Program; (ii) remove a reference in 9VAC25-210-340 to a repealed section; and (iii) change the term "local and regional water supply plan" to "water supply plan" for consistency with recent amendments to 9VAC25-780.

Issues: There are no direct impacts on the public. There are no disadvantages to the public. The primary advantage to the agency is that the amendments will allow the agency and surface water permit applicants under the VWP Permit Program to utilize regulations that reflect current requirements in the State Water Control Law and the Local and Regional Water Supply Planning regulation and improve the understanding of the VWP regulation, which in turn contributes to the efficient and effective functioning of government. There are no disadvantages to the agency or the Commonwealth.

Department of Planning and Budget Economic Impact Analysis:

The Department of Planning and Budget (DPB) has analyzed the economic impact of this proposed regulation in accordance with § 2.2-4007.04 of the Code of Virginia and Executive Order 19. The analysis presented represents DPB's best estimate of the potential economic impacts as of the date of this analysis.¹

Summary of the Proposed Amendments to Regulation. The State Water Control Board (board) proposes to update references and terminology and amend text for clarity.

Background. On October 9, 2024, updates to the Local and Regional Water Supply Planning (9VAC25-780) regulation became effective in response to Chapter 1105 of the 2020 Acts of Assembly. Prior to the updates, local governments had the option of either submitting a local water supply plan or participating in a regional planning unit in the submittal of a regional water supply plan. However, Chapter 1105 eliminated the option of submitting a local water supply plan. This elimination was reflected in one of the updates to 9VAC25-780, and other sections of this regulation were also repealed for clarity. However, the current Virginia Water Protection Permit Program Regulation (9VAC25-210) still has several references to "local or regional water supply plan." Since localities now must plan regionally and may no longer submit a local water supply plan, the board proposes to remove "local or regional" in each instance where the phrase "local or regional water supply plan" appears in the current regulation. In addition, certain references in the current Virginia Water Protection Permit Program Regulation are not accurate because they refer to sections of the Local and Regional Water Supply Planning regulation that were repealed in 2024. Consequently, the Board also proposes to update those references.

Estimated Benefits and Costs. The proposed amendments do not change existing requirements. Nevertheless, the proposed amendments are moderately beneficial in that clarity is improved for readers of the regulation, and the use of updated references will also help readers find the applicable information in those references.

Businesses and Other Entities Affected. The Virginia Water Protection Permit Program Regulation primarily applies to surface water withdrawal permittees. Out of 109 active Virginia water protection surface water withdrawal permits, there are 51 municipal, 19 commercial, 15 hydropower, 6 fossil fuel power, 6 irrigation, 6 mining, 4 agricultural, 1 industrial, and 1 nuclear power permittees. The Code requires DPB to assess whether an adverse impact may result from the proposed regulation.² An adverse impact is indicated if there is any increase in net cost or reduction in net benefit for any entity, even if the benefits exceed the costs for all entities combined.³ The proposed amendments neither increase net cost nor reduce net benefit for any entity. Thus, no adverse impact is indicated.

Small Businesses⁴ Affected.⁵ The proposed amendments do not adversely affect small businesses.

Localities⁶ Affected.⁷ The proposed amendments neither disproportionately affect any particular locality nor affect costs for local governments.

Projected Impact on Employment. The proposed amendments do not affect employment.

Effects on the Use and Value of Private Property. The proposed amendments do not substantively affect the use and value of private property. The proposed amendments do not affect real estate development costs.

_____________________________

¹ See § 2.2-4007.04 A of the Code of Virginia.

² See § 2.2-4007.04 D of the Code of Virginia.

³ Statute does not define "adverse impact," state whether only Virginia entities should be considered, nor indicate whether an adverse impact results from regulatory requirements mandated by legislation. As a result, DPB has adopted a definition of adverse impact that assesses changes in net costs and benefits for each affected Virginia entity that directly results from discretionary changes to the regulation.

⁴ Pursuant to § 2.2-4007.04, small business is defined as "a business entity, including its affiliates, that (i) is independently owned and operated and (ii) employs fewer than 500 full-time employees or has gross annual sales of less than $6 million."

⁵ See §§ 2.2-4007.04 A and 2.2-4007.1 C of the Code of Virginia.

⁶ "Locality" can refer to either local governments or the locations in the Commonwealth where the activities relevant to the regulatory change are most likely to occur.

⁷ Section 2.2-4007.04 defines "particularly affected" as bearing disproportionate material impact.

Agency Response to Economic Impact Analysis: The State Water Control Board has reviewed the economic impact analysis prepared by the Department of Planning and Budget and has no comment.

Summary:

The amendments conform the Virginia Water Protection Permit Program Regulation (9VAC25-210) to recent amendments to Local and Regional Water Supply Planning (9VAC25-780) by removing "local or regional" from the description of water supply plans, clarifying pre-application procedures, and removing obsolete cross-references.

9VAC25-210-320. Preapplication procedures for new or expanded surface water withdrawals.

A. Preapplication review panel. At the request of a potential applicant for a surface water withdrawal proposing to the Department of Environmental Quality to withdraw 90 million gallons a month or greater, a preapplication review panel shall be convened prior to submission of a VWP application. The preapplication review panel shall assist potential applicants that are proposing surface water withdrawals with the early identification of issues related to the protection of beneficial instream and offstream uses of state waters and the identification of the affected stream reach. DEQ shall notify the Virginia Marine Resources Commission, the Virginia Institute of Marine Science, the Virginia Department of Wildlife Resources, the Virginia Department of Conservation and Recreation, the Virginia Department of Health, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, and other appropriate local, state, and federal agencies of the preapplication review panel request. These agencies shall participate to the extent practicable in the preapplication review panel by providing information and guidance on the potential natural resource impacts and regulatory implications of the options being considered by the applicant and shall provide comments within 60 days of the initial meeting of the preapplication panel.

B. Preapplication public notice. For new or expanded surface water withdrawals requiring an individual VWP permit and proposing to withdraw 90 million gallons a month or greater, a potential applicant shall provide information on the project, shall provide an opportunity for public comment on the proposed project, and shall assist in identifying public concerns or issues prior to filing a VWP individual permit application.

1. Except as provided in this subsection, the potential applicant shall provide for publication of notice once a week for two consecutive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation serving the locality where the surface water withdrawal is proposed to be located.

2. If requested by any person, the potential applicant shall hold at least one public information meeting. Notice of any public information meeting held pursuant to this subsection shall be provided at least 14 days prior to the public information meeting date and shall be published in the same manner as required in subdivision 1 of this subsection. A potential applicant shall submit the notice to DEQ for posting on the DEQ website. At a minimum, any notice required by this subsection shall include:

a. A statement of the potential applicant's intent to apply for a VWP permit for a surface water withdrawal;

b. The proposed location of the surface water withdrawal;

c. Information on how the public may request a public information meeting or, in the alternative, the date, time, and location of the public information meeting;

d. The name, address, and telephone number of the potential applicant, or an authorized representative who can answer questions or receive comments on the proposed surface water withdrawal; and

e. A statement of how oral or written public comments will be used.

3. In accordance with the provisions of 9VAC25-780-50 C 11 and 9VAC25-780-150, a The potential applicant shall not be required to publish public notice or provide an opportunity for a public information meeting if a:

a. A public meeting has been held within two years prior to the submittal of an application for a VWP permit on a local or regional water supply plan, which includes the proposed project; and

b. The public meeting was held in accordance with 9VAC25-780-55 or 9VAC25-780-150.

4. The potential applicant shall maintain a list of persons making comment and their addresses and shall make a good faith effort to notify commenters at the address provided by the commenter when the public notice for the draft VWP individual permit is available.

9VAC25-210-340. Application requirements for surface water withdrawals.

A. Persons proposing to initiate a new or expanded surface water withdrawal not excluded from requirements of this chapter by 9VAC25-210-310, proposing to reapply for a current permitted withdrawal, or a Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) license or relicense associated with a surface water withdrawal, shall apply for a VWP permit.

B. In addition to informational requirements of 9VAC25-210-80 B and, if applicable, 9VAC25-210-80 C, applications for surface water withdrawals or a FERC license or relicense associated with a surface water withdrawal shall include:

1. As part of identifying the project purpose, a narrative describing the water supply issues that form the basis of the proposed project purpose.

2. The drainage area, the average annual flow and the median monthly flows at the withdrawal point, and historical low flows if available.

3. The average daily withdrawal; the maximum daily, monthly, annual, and instantaneous withdrawals; and information on the variability of the demand by season. If the project has multiple intake structures, provide for each individual intake structure and the cumulative volumes for the entire surface water withdrawal system.

4. The monthly consumptive use volume in million gallons and the average daily return flow in million gallons per day of the proposed project and the location of the return flow, including the latitude and longitude and the drainage area in square miles at the discharge point.

5. Information on flow dependent beneficial uses along the affected stream reach. For projects that propose a transfer of water resources from a major river basin to another major river basin, this analysis should include both the source and receiving basins.

a. Evaluation of the flow dependent instream and offstream beneficial uses. Instream beneficial uses include the protection of fish and wildlife habitat, maintenance of waste assimilation, recreation, navigation, and cultural and aesthetic values. Offstream beneficial uses include domestic (including public water supply), agricultural, electric power generation, and commercial and industrial uses.

b. The aquatic life, including species and habitat requirements.

c. How the proposed withdrawal will alter flows.

6. Information on the proposed use of and need for the surface water and information on how demand for surface water was determined (e.g., per capita use, population growth rates, new uses, changes to service areas, and if applicable, acreage irrigated and evapotranspiration effects). If during the water supply planning process, the need for the withdrawal was established, the applicant may submit the planning process information, provided that the submittal addresses all requirements of 9VAC25-210-360. The department shall deem such a submittal as meeting the requirements of this subsection. For surface water withdrawals for public water supply, see also 9VAC25-780-100 and 9VAC25-780-130.

7. Information describing the intake structure, to include intake screen mesh size and intake velocity.

8. For withdrawals proposed from an impoundment, the following:

a. Description of the flow or release control structures, including the minimum rate of flow, in cubic feet per second, size and capacity of the structure, and the mechanism to control the release.

b. Surface area in acres, maximum depth in feet, normal pool elevation, total storage capacity, and unusable storage volume in acre-feet.

c. The stage-storage relationship. For example, the volume of water in the impoundment at varying stages of water depth.

9. Whether the proposed surface water withdrawal is addressed in the water supply plan that covers the area in which the withdrawal is proposed to be located. If the proposed withdrawal is included, provide a discussion as to how the proposed withdrawal is addressed in the water supply plan, specifically in terms of projected demand, analysis of alternatives, and water conservation measures. If all or a portion of the withdrawn water will be transferred to an area not covered by the plan, the discussion shall also include the water supply plan for the area of the receiving watershed.

10. An alternatives analysis for the proposed surface water withdrawal, including at a minimum the criteria in 9VAC25-210-360.

11. For new or expanded surface water withdrawals proposing to withdraw 90 million gallons a month or greater, a summary of the steps taken to seek public input as required by 9VAC25-210-320 and an identification of the issues raised during the course of the public information meeting process.

12. For new or expanded surface water withdrawals that involve a transfer of water between major river basins that may impact a river basin in another state, a plan describing procedures to notify potentially affected persons, both in and outside of Virginia, of the proposed project.

13. For surface water withdrawals, other than for public water supply, information to demonstrate that alternate sources of water supply are available to support the operation of the facility during times of reduced instream flow.

14. For surface water withdrawals for public water supply, a water auditing plan for an annual water loss audit in accordance with the American Water Works Association (AWWA) methodology for water loss auditing using the most recent version of the AWWA Water Audit Software or another methodology approved by the department that estimates water loss.

a. A water loss audit using an approved methodology shall be conducted annually. The requirement to conduct an annual water loss audit shall begin upon permit issuance. By the end of the first year of the permit term, the permittee shall submit documentation to the department that the water loss audit has been initiated. This documentation shall include activities completed during the first year of the permit term.

b. The applicant shall report the results of the annual water loss audits in a report submitted at a minimum of every three years.

15. For surface water withdrawals for public water supply, a leak detection and repair plan shall be submitted. The leak detection and repair plan shall indicate how its implementation will be informed by the results of the annual water loss audit process and shall be updated during each new permit term. The plan shall include:

a. A description of how the water loss audit results are expected to inform prioritization of actions to address water loss;

b. Where practicable, a process for the identification of equipment needs to quantify and reduce water loss;

c. Where practicable, a schedule for inspection of equipment and distribution systems for actual water losses; and

d. In the report required by subdivision B 14 b of this section, a description of the plan's effectiveness in addressing water loss, including revisions to those elements of the leak detection and repair plan that can be improved over the short term and long term.

16. For surface water withdrawals for commercial and industrial users, a water auditing plan for a water loss audit to be conducted beginning in the first three years of the permit term. The plan shall include a description of the methodology used to determine the water loss for the operation and the quantity of water used throughout the facility.

a. A water audit using this methodology shall be conducted once every three years. The requirement to conduct a water loss audit shall begin upon permit issuance. The permittee shall submit documentation to include activities completed during the first three years of the permit term.

b. The applicant shall conduct a water loss audit and report the results of the water loss audits in a report submitted every three years.

17. For surface water withdrawals for commercial and industrial users, a leak detection and repair plan shall be submitted. The leak detection and repair plan shall indicate how its implementation will be informed by the results of the water loss audit process and shall be updated during each new permit term. The plan shall include:

a. A description of how the water audit results are expected to inform prioritization of actions to address water loss;

b. Where practicable, a process for the identification of equipment needs to quantify and reduce water loss;

c. Where practicable, a schedule for inspection of equipment and piping systems for actual water losses; and

d. In the report required by subdivision B 16 b of this section, a description of the leak detection and repair plan's effectiveness in addressing water loss, including revisions to those elements of the leak detection and repair plan that can be improved over the short term and long term.

18. For surface water withdrawals for agricultural users, a water auditing plan for an annual water loss audit that shall be conducted annually or periodically based on agricultural management plans or irrigation management plans, including the anticipated crop rotation schedule or livestock growth stages. The water auditing plan shall include an estimate of water loss for the agricultural operation and a description of the methodology used to determine the quantity of water used throughout the agricultural operation.

a. A water audit using this methodology shall be conducted. The requirement to conduct a water loss audit shall begin upon permit issuance. By the end of the first year of the permit term, the permittee shall submit documentation to the department that the water loss audit has been initiated. This documentation shall include activities completed during the first year of the permit term.

b. The applicant shall report the results of the water loss audit in a report submitted at a minimum every three years.

19. For surface water withdrawals for agricultural users, a leak detection and repair plan shall be submitted. The leak detection and repair plan shall indicate how its implementation will be informed by the results of the water loss audit process and shall be updated during each new permit term. The plan shall include:

a. A description of how the water audit results are expected to inform prioritization of actions to address water loss;

b. Where practicable, a schedule for inspection of equipment and distribution systems for actual water losses; and

c. In the report required by subdivision B 18 b of this section, a description of the leak detection and repair plan's effectiveness in addressing water loss, including revisions to those elements of the leak detection and repair plan that can be improved over the short term and long term.

C. Applications for an Emergency Virginia Water Protection Permit.

1. Applications for an Emergency Virginia Water Protection Permit to address a public water supply emergency shall include the information noted in subdivisions 1 a through 1 o of this subsection. The JPA may be used for emergency application purposes, provided that all of the information in subdivisions 1 a through 1 o of this subsection is included:

a. The applicant's legal name, mailing address, telephone number, and if applicable, fax number and email address;

b. If different from applicant, name, mailing address, telephone number, and if applicable, fax number and email address of property owner;

c. If applicable, authorized agent's name, mailing address, telephone number, and if applicable, fax number and email address;

d. Name of water body or water bodies, or receiving waters, as applicable;

e. Name of the city or county where the project occurs;

f. Signed and dated signature page (electronic submittals containing the original signature page, such as that contained in a scanned document file are acceptable);

g. Permit application fee in accordance with 9VAC25-20;

h. The drainage area, the average annual flow and the median monthly flows at the withdrawal point, and historical low flows if available;

i. Information on the aquatic life along the affected stream reach, including species and habitat requirements;

j. Recent and current water use, including monthly water use in the previous calendar year and weekly water use in the six months prior to the application. The application shall identify the sources of such water and also identify any water purchased from other water suppliers;

k. A description of the severity of the public water supply emergency, including (i) for reservoirs, an estimate of days of remaining supply at current rates of use and replenishment; (ii) for wells, current production; and (iii) for intakes, current streamflow;

l. A description of mandatory water conservation measures taken or imposed by the applicant and the dates when the measures were implemented; for the purposes of obtaining an Emergency Virginia Water Protection Permit, mandatory water conservation measures shall include the prohibition of lawn and landscape watering, vehicle washing, watering of recreation fields, refilling of swimming pools, and washing of paved surfaces;

m. An estimate of water savings realized by implementing mandatory water conservation measures;

n. Documentation that the applicant has exhausted all management actions that would minimize the threat to public welfare, safety, and health and will avoid the need to obtain an emergency permit and that are consistent with existing permit limitations; and

o. Any other information that demonstrates that the condition is a substantial threat to public health or safety.

2. Within 14 days after the issuance of an Emergency Virginia Water Protection Permit, the permit holder shall apply for a VWP permit under the other provisions of this chapter.

9VAC25-210-360. Evaluation of project alternatives for surface water withdrawals.

The applicant shall demonstrate to the satisfaction of the department that the project meets an established need for water to meet the project purpose. In establishing need, the applicant shall provide the following information:

1. Existing supply sources, yields, and demands, including:

a. Peak day and average daily withdrawal;

b. The public water supply safe yield and lowest daily flow of record;

c. Types of water uses; and

d. Existing water conservation measures and drought response plan, including what conditions trigger their implementation.

2. Projected demands over a minimum 30-year planning period, including the following:

a. Projected demand contained in the local or regional water supply plan developed in accordance with 9VAC25-780 or for the project service area, if such area is smaller than the planning area; if applicable or

b. Statistical population (growth) trends; if applicable, projected demands by use type; projected demand without water conservation measures; and projected demands with long-term water conservation measures.

3. Any alternatives analysis conducted specifically for withdrawals for public water supply shall include:

a. The range of alternatives to be analyzed by the applicant as follows:

(1) All applicable alternatives contained in the local or regional water supply plan developed in accordance with 9VAC25-780;

(2) Alternatives that are practicable or feasible from both a technical and economic standpoint that had not been identified in the local or regional water supply plan developed in accordance with 9VAC25-780;

(3) Alternatives that are available to the applicant but not necessarily under the current jurisdiction of the applicant; and

(4) Water conservation measures that could be considered as a means to reduce demand for each alternative considered by the applicant.

b. The applicant shall provide a narrative description that outlines the opportunities and status of regionalization efforts undertaken by the applicant.

c. The criteria used to evaluate each alternative for the purpose of establishing the least environmentally damaging practicable alternative, which includes but is not limited to:

(1) Demonstration that the proposed alternative meets the project purpose and project demonstrated need as documented pursuant to this section;

(2) Availability of the alternative to the applicant;

(3) Evaluation of interconnectivity of water supply systems, both existing and proposed;

(4) Evaluation of the cost of the alternative on an equivalent basis;

(5) Evaluation of alternative public water supply safe yields;

(6) Presence and potential impact of alternative on state and federally listed threatened and endangered species;

(7) Presence and potential impact of alternative on wetlands and streams (based on maps and aerial photos for all alternatives, field delineation required for preferred alternative);

(8) Evaluation of effects on instream flow; and

(9) Water quality considerations, including:

(a) Land use within a watershed where the type of land use may impact the water quality of the source;

(b) The presence of impaired streams and the type of impairment;

(c) The location of point source discharges; and

(d) Potential threats to water quality other than those listed in this subdivision 3 c (9).

4. Any alternatives analysis conducted for surface water withdrawals other than for public water supply shall include the following items of subdivision 3 of this section: subdivisions 3 a (3), 3 a (4), and 3 c. The analysis shall also include applicable items of subdivisions 3 a (1), 3 a (2), and 3 b of this section.